Miss American Pie

If you haven’t tried our chocolate covered strawberry pie, it’s a must! A pistachio and almond crust, strawberry infused dark chocolate custard, topped with coconut cream and a chocolate covered strawberry. So decadent and delicious! #treatyoself We also have old-fashioned banana cream, black and blueberry crisp, strawberry rhubarb crisp, and signature probably coming out later. Plus more treats. Come on down ;)

Our Mission at Miss American Pie is- To provide unrivaled desserts and pastries, in a relaxed, fun-loving atmosphere, that brings joy, facilitates community, and promotes a lifestyle of authentic relationships. When I decided to open Miss American Pie, I knew that it would be hard. But, I also knew that nothing worth doing is easy, and that this is what I’ve been called to do. The Divine inspiration to open this shop and to follow the Lord’s calling as best I can had been im...Continue reading

Well, this weekends weather sucks. But, if you’re a New Yorker, you’re probably up for a little challenge. Put your rain boots on and come on down for a slice. This is one of my favorites, black and blueberry crisp. Plus, I made an fresh batch of biscuits today because we sold out early. Or, don’t forget we are closed on Mondays, so pick up a whole pie for your memorial day gathering tomorrow.

We have some whole pies available that I made this morning before deciding to be closed today. Who wants one?!? - Key Lime - The Signature Pie - Black and Blueberry Crisp - Cherry Crumb... - Strawberry Rhubarb (standard pastry crust or gluten free crisp) - 1 dozen chocolate chip cookies - 1/2 dozen ugly monster cookies Call to reserve, pick up before 7pm. Or place an order for tomorrow. 718-789-3747 Or...if you really must have a slice, a bacon egg and cheese, or an avocado toast, we are still open on Grubhub, Doordash, and Chownow,

A perfect lunch. Bacon, egg, and cheese on a cheddar biscuit and a fat slice of signature pie. I definitely didn’t eat enough pie during my break...I need to make up for lost time.

Have you tried one of our winter flavors? They are some of my all-time favorites and they’re only here for a limited time. We’re excited to be back in full swing this weekend. And we missed seeing you all the last couple weeks! Stop by and warm up with a coffee, tea, or hot chocolate and a slice. Or a bacon, egg, and cheese on one of these yummy biscuits!

WE’RE BACK! MAP will reopen tomorrow at 10am, fully stocked with coffee, teas, sweets and savories, and everyone’s favorite bacon, egg, and cheese on a cheddar biscuit. Come on down and get your fix. We’re happy to be serving up some Love this weekend ... Open 10am-9pm

This is Michael. He has been with us since the very beginning. He was hired as a barista the first week we were open and is the only employee who has stuck around through all of the ups and downs of our first year and a half. Over and over Michael has proven his dedication to MAP and his ability to adapt to ever changing expectations. From espresso drinks to kitchen prep, he excels at every new task he is assigned, always going the extra mile to learn and perfect our process.... Michael goes above and beyond his official job description by contributing to the promotion, progress, and success of our brand in any way he can. He has a special gift of attending to the needs of guests, and is a delight to work with. Despite being our youngest employee, Michael is always a positive encouragement to our team, edifying and building us up when we need a new perspective. He is a dependable and valuable asset and we’re grateful to have him on the MAP team.